State College, PA - Centre County - Central Pennsylvania - Home of Penn State University

Police say Alleged Cemetery Vandal is State College Arsonist

by on June 03, 2014 1:18 PM

The man who already faces charges for allegedly vandalizing a cemetery in Ferguson Township now faces arson charges in State College.

State College police have obtained arrest warrants for Timothy L. Penrod, 24, of State College, for two arson fires that occurred May 18 in State College within minutes of each other.

Police intend to serve the arrest warrants in court Wednesday as Penrod is slated to appear before a judge for his charges connected to the Pine Hall Cemetery vandalism in Ferguson Township.

The first arson occurred about 11 p.m. in the 700 block of Windsor Court destroying a large wooden shed located roughly 20 feet from a residence causing roughly $10,000 in damage. Items lost included a lawn mower and several bicycles.

Authorities say it appeared someone intentionally set the fire using a small amount of accelerant at the doorway to the shed. Police say it's possible someone gained access to the shed from a bike path to the rear of the property.

The second arson was reported around 11:15 p.m. a few blocks away in the 1000 block of Bayberry Drive across from Orchard Park at the end of the same bike path. Police say the fire covered the entire front of the home, where the siding, windows and wooden deck furniture were "soaked" with lighter fluid, according to court records.

"The wooden furniture was set on fire with the intent of the furniture then setting the house on fire," the affidavit states.

Police say charcoal lighter fluid was used to start the fire and investigators located a canister of the fluid in a trash can near the bike path. Authorities say fingerprints were obtained from the container.

A neighbor's surveillance video reportedly captured the incident. Police say the footage indicates the fire was set about 11:06 p.m. and shows a person walking onto the deck and then heading toward the bike path.

Soon after, a passerby alerted the two residents inside about the fire and they were able to safely exit.

Authorities say based upon the amount of fluid sprayed on the home, if the fire had spread, it likely would have blocked the home's front exits. Police say the fire caused roughly $2,000 in damage.

Further investigation, police say, showed Penrod did not return home May 18 to his assisted living apartment before his 11 p.m. curfew, but instead returned at 11:45 p.m. at which point police interviewed him about his activities that evening.

During the interview, Penrod allegedly made comments regarding his mental health state and he was then transported for medical care. After Penrod's release, police interviewed him again at his home in front of staff. During the interview, Penrod allegedly admitted to seeing at least one of the fires while he was out, but denied any involvement.

The following day, staff at his assisted living home reported Penrod missing. It was the same day the cemetery vandalism reportedly occurred in Ferguson Township. The next day, Penrod returned home where authorities took him into custody for treatment and a parole violation.

In a later interview, police say Penrod allegedly admitted to setting the fires.

Ferguson Township police filed charges Friday against Penrod for allegedly toppling 15 headstones at Pine Hall Cemetery in May.

Police also allege Penrod burned at least one American flag posted at a grave and attempted to enter the secured maintenance shed through a window.

In that case, police collected several pieces of evidence at the scene, which led to Penrod's arrest, including a baseball hat, cell phone, beer can, beer and food receipts, footprint and other forensic evidence.

Popular Stories:

Judge Sentences State College Holiday Burglar to State Prison

Authorities Remove Alligator from Boalsburg Home

Demolition Underway at Former Arby's Site to Make Room for Metropolitan Building

New Construction Project Set to Begin on Route 322

Centre County Police Officers Will Deliver Torch to Special Olympics Opening Ceremonies


Jennifer Miller is a reporter for She has worked in journalism since 2005. She's covered news at the local, state and national level with an emphasis on crime and local government.
Next Article
Penn State Football: Worse Things Than Turning Away Talent For Franklin And Staff
June 03, 2014 1:00 PM
by Ben Jones
Penn State Football: Worse Things Than Turning Away Talent For Franklin And Staff
Disclaimer: Copyright © 2019 All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

order food online