State College, PA - Centre County - Central Pennsylvania - Home of Penn State University

Trustees Lubrano and Dandrea Have Heated Debate on Special Meetings

by and on January 15, 2015 7:05 PM

Board of Trustees members Anthony Lubrano and Rick Dandrea went to battle at Thursday’s Committee on Governance and Long-Range Planning meeting, arguing about the board’s provision to call a special meeting.

Dandrea was insistent on raising the minimum requirement to call a special meeting – which currently requires approval from seven members – to instead require a quorum of voting members, which is needed for official business to be transacted.

This came in response to the special meeting called in December by the alumni-elected trustees to consider Anthony Lubrano’s resolution that would add Penn State as plaintiff in State Sen. Jake Corman’s lawsuit. When the legislation first came to the floor during the November board meeting, Vice Chair Kathleen Casey motioned to review it in a closed executive session before voting because it involves a legal matter.

“What’s interesting to me is that it was tabled at a time when the trial was scheduled to begin before [tomorrow’s board] meeting,” Lubrano said. “What you’re doing here is very transparent. You don’t want dissent. You talk about not wanting to waste resources by holding a meeting where official business can’t be conducted and that’s laughable considering the millions and millions this board has wasted.”

Dandrea voiced his belief that Lubrano purposely waited until the night before the November board meeting to circulate the resolution, opining that it was “a tactic to set this up for a special meeting.”

“You give me too much credit,” Lubrano responded, explaining that it was circulated late because new information that prompted the resolution came up just a week earlier.

Dandrea held up the one-page resolution, asking, “How long does it take to prepare this?”

“Well, Rick, I like to do quality work,” Lubrano fired back.

Alumni-elected trustee Barbara Doran added that it would be misguided to alter the provision on calling a special meeting based on a single issue with the current guideline.

“To change rules based on one incident, a one-time disagreement would not be wise,” Doran said. “It’s a mechanism that’s in there for the minority to be able to speak up.”

That minority, in this case, is the nine alumni-elected trustees who have tended to vote as a bloc since stepping onto the board. Chair Keith Masser said that the minority group of trustees can utilize other means to publicly voice their opinions.

“There are other forums that you can use to have a venting session instead of a meeting in which you can’t conduct business that will waste people’s time and resources,” Masser said.

There was no decision made on the future of special meetings as this was just a committee discussion, but legislation moving to alter the provision could come up at the committee’s next meeting in March.

In addition to discussing special meetings, the committee voted on Student Trustee Guidelines that outline the process of selecting the now-codified member of the board going forward. There will be a core team and selection committee that recommend candidates and perform interviews. The guidelines passed through the committee unanimously.

The committee also unanimously passed guidelines on selecting the faculty trustee position after minimal discussion. They reviewed the procedures to select agricultural delegates and discussed tightening up the process.

The Presidential Search Review Task Force, chaired by trustee Thomas Poole, is working on a set of recommendations for future presidential searches, although he said “we hope not to use them anytime soon.” The task force is studying the process behind Eric Barron’s hiring, and plans to interview Barron himself for input on how things looked from his side as a candidate.

Popular Stories:

Penn State Battles Issues of Sexual Assault & Racism

Former NCAA Chair Admits to Not Reading Freeh Report Prior to Sanctioning Penn State

BOT Committee Approves Building Renovations, Health System Merger

Penn State Targeted by Constant Barrage of Cyber Security Threats

Penn State Communications to Launch “Brand Storybook”

Trustees OK Lasch Building Renovations

Penn State Football: Report Values Nittany Lions At Just Over A Half Billion

Postmortem Notes From The First College Football Playoff Season

10 Rounds of Answers About Penn Staters Who’ve Declared Early for NFL Draft

Penn State Football: Nittany Lions Hit New Academic High During Fall Semester

Penn State Football: Virginia Tech Series Light At End Of Uneventful Scheduling Tunnel

Penn State Soccer Player Brett Gravatt Seriously Injured In Snowboarding Accident

This post was originally published by the staff at Onward State. Follow Onward State on Twitter @OnwardState.

Zach Berger is the managing editor of He graduated from Penn State University in 2014 with a degree in print journalism. Zach enjoys writing about a variety of topics ranging from football to government, music, and everything in between.
Next Article
Former NCAA Chair Admits to Not Reading Freeh Report Prior to Sanctioning Penn State
January 15, 2015 3:20 PM
by Onward State Staff by Ted Hozza
Former NCAA Chair Admits to Not Reading Freeh Report Prior to Sanctioning Penn State
Disclaimer: Copyright © 2020 All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

order food online